Stila was the first one that I tried, and I immediately liked it. It is the only liquid contender in the group and from the beginning it is LEAGUES above other liquids I have used in the past. And trust me, I have tried them all. It is SUPER user friendly and makes a great cat eye for the weekend merrymaking events. I have to be honest, I was really impressed with this eyeliner because it lasted through a two hour migraine headache nap without smudging a smidge. If I love all of the eyeliners this much, then I will definitely have a problem picking a winner.
Round Two: Smashbox
Disclaimer: I am not a beauty guru, makeup expert, circus clown in training, or anything of the like. I am not reviewing these products for any reason other than sharing my experience with my faithful readers. Hope you enjoy! Feedback welcome.